fix(housekeeping): preserve audit reasons and completed effects

docs/superpowers/plans/2026-09-05-housekeeping-backend-integrity.md

@@ -0,0 +1,45 @@
+# Housekeeping Backend Integrity Implementation Plan
+
+> **For agentic workers:** Use superpowers:executing-plans task-by-task. Keep checkpoints independently verifiable.
+
+**Goal:** Complete the approved backend review, starting with reproducible audit and external-completion defects.
+
+**Architecture:** Retain the six domain services and production adapters. Follow every operation from its public entrypoint through authorization, validation, storage, external effects and audit. Route coverage is not functional completion.
+
+**Tech Stack:** TypeScript, Drizzle/MySQL, Vitest, Next.js, pnpm.
+
+**Spec:** Backend scope approved in conversation on 2026-09-05: complete operations, permissions, validation, transactions, concurrency, audit and partial outcomes; preserve UI and production routing.
+
+## Global constraints
+
+- Work in the canonical checkout on `codex/housekeeping-rebuild-stepwise`; no worktrees.
+- Preserve untracked local files and existing administration routes.
+- Keep PR 53 draft and update English and Dutch evidence after each verified push.
+- No production writes or deployment. Missing local services block live acceptance, not implementation.
+
+## Task 1: Preserve reasons through service and production audit
+
+Files: Content and Economy `services/mutations.ts`, `services/mutations-production.ts`; new `src/features/housekeeping/backend-audit-integrity.test.ts`.
+
+Interfaces: optional normalized `reason` in mutation context; existing `AuditEntry.reason` at persistence.
+
+- [ ] Exercise real service plus production adapter with captured audit writes. For database and external operations assert `entry.reason === "Remove obsolete resource"` from a whitespace-padded invocation.
+- [ ] Run `pnpm exec vitest run --coverage.enabled=false src/features/housekeeping/backend-audit-integrity.test.ts`; verify missing reason fails.
+- [ ] Normalize once at the service boundary, conditionally include the reason in the adapter context, persist in every adapter audit outcome.
+- [ ] Repeat focused tests, including absent reasons and audit-failure outcomes.
+
+## Task 2: Preserve completed Hotel external effects when audit fails
+
+Files: Hotel `services/mutations-production.ts` and its existing test.
+
+Interfaces: existing `HotelMutationSnapshot.completion`, with `status: "partial", external: "completed", audit: "unavailable"`.
+
+- [ ] Execute `room.runtime` with successful effect but failing success-audit writer; assert resolved snapshot with partial completion and no failure audit.
+- [ ] Verify failure against current production adapter.
+- [ ] Separate external-execution errors from completion-audit errors. Preserve intent-before-effect and original external failure semantics.
+- [ ] Test failed intent prevents execution and failed failure-audit does not replace the original exception.
+- [ ] Run focused suites, typecheck, scoped Biome, full suite and review the diff; commit exact paths and push with normal hooks.
+
+## Subsequent independently verified blocks
+
+These are open audit scope, not completed tasks: Economy marketplace/voucher concurrency; operation-level parity and validation across Content, Economy, Hotel, People, System and Operations; all corresponding API and legacy entrypoints. Each block requires concrete findings, regression tests and its own implementation steps before changes. Do not mark the whole backend complete from Tasks 1-2.

src/features/housekeeping/backend-audit-integrity.test.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,183 @@
+import { describe, expect, it } from "vitest";
+import type { AuditEntry } from "@/lib/services/audit";
+import { createContentMutationService } from "./domains/content/services/mutations";
+import {
+	ContentCommittedExternalFailure,
+	createContentProductionMutationAdapter,
+} from "./domains/content/services/mutations-production";
+import { createEconomyMutationService } from "./domains/economy/services/mutations";
+import {
+	createEconomyProductionMutationAdapter,
+	EconomyCommittedExternalFailure,
+} from "./domains/economy/services/mutations-production";
+import { createHotelCommands } from "./domains/hotel/commands/hotel-commands";
+import { createHotelMutationService } from "./domains/hotel/services/mutations";
+import { createHotelProductionMutationAdapter } from "./domains/hotel/services/mutations-production";
+import type { HousekeepingCapabilityContext } from "./foundation/contracts";
+
+const capability: HousekeepingCapabilityContext = {
+	actor: { id: 42, username: "operator", rank: 7 },
+	isSuperAdmin: false,
+	has: () => true,
+	hasAny: () => true,
+	hasAll: () => true,
+};
+
+describe("Backend audit reason integrity", () => {
+	it("retains the Hotel command reason through execution and partial audit completion", async () => {
+		const entries: AuditEntry[] = [];
+		const service = createHotelMutationService(
+			createHotelProductionMutationAdapter({
+				transaction: async (run) => run({}),
+				writeAudit: async (entry) => {
+					entries.push(entry);
+					if (entry.outcome === "success") throw new Error("audit unavailable");
+				},
+				executeOperation: async () => ({
+					before: null,
+					after: { dispatched: true },
+				}),
+			}),
+			async () => capability,
+		);
+		const command = createHotelCommands(service).find(
+			(item) => item.operation === "room.runtime",
+		);
+		if (!command) throw new Error("missing runtime command");
+		const result = await command.execute(
+			{
+				capability,
+				correlationId: "hotel-reason",
+				ipAddress: "127.0.0.1",
+				reason: "  Reload after maintenance  ",
+			},
+			{ roomId: 7, action: "reload" },
+		);
+		expect(result).toMatchObject({
+			ok: true,
+			correlationId: "hotel-reason",
+			completion: {
+				status: "partial",
+				external: "completed",
+				audit: "unavailable",
+			},
+		});
+		expect(entries.map((entry) => entry.reason)).toEqual([
+			"Reload after maintenance",
+			"Reload after maintenance",
+		]);
+	});
+	for (const domain of ["content", "economy"] as const) {
+		it.each(["failure", "partial", "absent", "blank"] as const)(
+			`${domain} preserves audit reason semantics for %s`,
+			async (scenario) => {
+				const entries: AuditEntry[] = [];
+				const dependencies = {
+					transaction: async <T>(run: (tx: unknown) => Promise<T>) => run({}),
+					writeAudit: async (entry: AuditEntry) => {
+						entries.push(entry);
+					},
+					executeOperation: async () => {
+						if (scenario === "failure")
+							throw new Error("transport unavailable");
+						if (scenario === "partial") {
+							const snapshot = {
+								before: { id: "7" },
+								after: { id: "7", saved: true },
+							};
+							throw domain === "content"
+								? new ContentCommittedExternalFailure(snapshot)
+								: new EconomyCommittedExternalFailure(snapshot);
+						}
+						return { before: null, after: { saved: true } };
+					},
+				};
+				const invocation = {
+					expectedActorId: 42,
+					correlationId: "outcome-check",
+					...(scenario === "absent"
+						? {}
+						: { reason: scenario === "blank" ? "   " : "  Maintenance  " }),
+				};
+				const result =
+					domain === "content"
+						? await createContentMutationService(
+								createContentProductionMutationAdapter(dependencies),
+								async () => capability,
+							).execute(invocation, "theme.update", {})
+						: await createEconomyMutationService(
+								createEconomyProductionMutationAdapter(dependencies),
+								async () => capability,
+							).execute(invocation, "catalog-page.change", {});
+				expect(result.ok).toBe(scenario !== "failure");
+				if (scenario === "partial")
+					expect(result).toMatchObject({
+						completion: {
+							status: "partial",
+							external: "failed",
+							audit: "persisted",
+						},
+					});
+				expect(entries.map((entry) => entry.outcome)).toEqual([
+					"intent",
+					scenario === "failure" || scenario === "partial"
+						? scenario
+						: "success",
+				]);
+				expect(entries.map((entry) => entry.reason)).toEqual(
+					scenario === "absent" || scenario === "blank"
+						? [undefined, undefined]
+						: ["Maintenance", "Maintenance"],
+				);
+			},
+		);
+		for (const external of [false, true]) {
+			it(`${domain} retains the normalized reason in ${external ? "external" : "database"} audit records`, async () => {
+				const entries: AuditEntry[] = [];
+				const dependencies = {
+					transaction: async <T>(run: (tx: unknown) => Promise<T>) => run({}),
+					writeAudit: async (entry: AuditEntry) => {
+						entries.push(entry);
+					},
+					executeOperation: async () => ({ before: { id: "7" }, after: null }),
+				};
+				const invocation = {
+					expectedActorId: 42,
+					correlationId: "reason-check",
+					reason: "  Remove obsolete resource  ",
+				};
+				const result =
+					domain === "content"
+						? await createContentMutationService(
+								createContentProductionMutationAdapter(dependencies),
+								async () => capability,
+							).execute(invocation, external ? "media.delete" : "tag.change", {
+								action: "delete",
+								id: "7",
+							})
+						: await createEconomyMutationService(
+								createEconomyProductionMutationAdapter(dependencies),
+								async () => capability,
+							).execute(
+								invocation,
+								external ? "badge.upload" : "voucher.change",
+								{ action: "delete", id: "7" },
+							);
+				expect(result.ok).toBe(true);
+				expect(
+					entries.map((entry) => ({
+						outcome: entry.outcome,
+						reason: entry.reason,
+					})),
+				).toEqual(
+					external
+						? [
+								{ outcome: "intent", reason: "Remove obsolete resource" },
+								{ outcome: "success", reason: "Remove obsolete resource" },
+							]
+						: [{ outcome: "success", reason: "Remove obsolete resource" }],
+				);
+			});
+		}
+	}
+});

src/features/housekeeping/domains/content/services/mutations-production.ts

@@ -82,6 +82,7 @@ function auditEntry(
 		action: `content.${operation}`,
 		target: "Content",
 		correlationId: context.correlationId,
+		...(context.reason === undefined ? {} : { reason: context.reason }),
 		domain: "content",
 		outcome,
 		before:

src/features/housekeeping/domains/content/services/mutations.ts

@@ -67,6 +67,7 @@ export interface ContentMutationContext {
 	readonly capability: HousekeepingCapabilityContext;
 	readonly correlationId: string;
 	readonly legacy: boolean;
+	readonly reason?: string;
 }
 
 export interface ContentMutationAdapter {
@@ -158,10 +159,8 @@ export function createContentMutationService(
 					invocation.correlationId,
 				);
 			}
-			if (
+			const reason = normalizeHousekeepingReason(invocation.reason);
-				requiresHousekeepingReason(false, input) &&
+			if (requiresHousekeepingReason(false, input) && !reason) {
-				!normalizeHousekeepingReason(invocation.reason)
-			) {
 				return fail(
 					"VALIDATION",
 					"errors.housekeeping.validation",
@@ -174,6 +173,7 @@ export function createContentMutationService(
 					capability,
 					correlationId: invocation.correlationId,
 					legacy: invocation.legacy === true,
+					...(reason === undefined ? {} : { reason }),
 				});
 				return ok(snapshot, invocation.correlationId, snapshot.completion);
 			} catch (error) {

src/features/housekeeping/domains/economy/services/mutations-production.ts

@@ -75,6 +75,7 @@ function auditEntry(
 		action: `economy.${operation}`,
 		target: "Economy",
 		correlationId: context.correlationId,
+		...(context.reason === undefined ? {} : { reason: context.reason }),
 		domain: "economy",
 		outcome,
 		before:

src/features/housekeeping/domains/economy/services/mutations.ts

@@ -63,6 +63,7 @@ export interface EconomyMutationContext {
 	readonly capability: HousekeepingCapabilityContext;
 	readonly correlationId: string;
 	readonly legacy: boolean;
+	readonly reason?: string;
 }
 export interface EconomyMutationAdapter {
 	execute(
@@ -134,10 +135,8 @@ export function createEconomyMutationService(
 					invocation.correlationId,
 				);
 			}
-			if (
+			const reason = normalizeHousekeepingReason(invocation.reason);
-				requiresHousekeepingReason(false, input) &&
+			if (requiresHousekeepingReason(false, input) && !reason) {
-				!normalizeHousekeepingReason(invocation.reason)
-			) {
 				return fail(
 					"VALIDATION",
 					"errors.housekeeping.validation",
@@ -150,6 +149,7 @@ export function createEconomyMutationService(
 					capability,
 					correlationId: invocation.correlationId,
 					legacy: invocation.legacy === true,
+					...(reason === undefined ? {} : { reason }),
 				});
 				return ok(snapshot, invocation.correlationId, snapshot.completion);
 			} catch (error) {

src/features/housekeeping/domains/hotel/commands/hotel-commands.ts

@@ -57,6 +57,7 @@ export function createHotelCommands(
 					{
 						correlationId: context.correlationId,
 						expectedActorId: context.capability.actor.id,
+						...(context.reason === undefined ? {} : { reason: context.reason }),
 					},
 					operation,
 					input,

src/features/housekeeping/domains/hotel/services/mutations-production.test.ts

@@ -45,6 +45,51 @@ function dependencies() {
 }
 
 describe("Hotel production mutation adapter", () => {
+	it("retains completed RCON delivery when the completion audit fails", async () => {
+		const deps = dependencies();
+		deps.writeAudit.mockImplementation(async (entry) => {
+			if (entry.outcome === "success") throw new Error("audit unavailable");
+		});
+		const result = await deps.adapter.execute(
+			"room.runtime",
+			{ roomId: 7, action: "reload" },
+			context,
+		);
+		expect(result).toMatchObject({
+			after: { operation: "room.runtime", state: "after" },
+			completion: {
+				status: "partial",
+				external: "completed",
+				audit: "unavailable",
+			},
+		});
+		expect(deps.writeAudit.mock.calls.map(([entry]) => entry.outcome)).toEqual([
+			"intent",
+			"success",
+		]);
+		expect(deps.executeOperation).toHaveBeenCalledTimes(1);
+	});
+
+	it("does not execute RCON when intent persistence fails", async () => {
+		const deps = dependencies();
+		deps.writeAudit.mockRejectedValueOnce(new Error("intent unavailable"));
+		await expect(
+			deps.adapter.execute("room.runtime", {}, context),
+		).rejects.toThrow("intent unavailable");
+		expect(deps.executeOperation).not.toHaveBeenCalled();
+	});
+
+	it("preserves the original RCON failure if failure auditing is unavailable", async () => {
+		const deps = dependencies();
+		const failure = new Error("RCON unavailable");
+		deps.executeOperation.mockRejectedValueOnce(failure);
+		deps.writeAudit.mockImplementation(async (entry) => {
+			if (entry.outcome === "failure") throw new Error("audit unavailable");
+		});
+		await expect(
+			deps.adapter.execute("room.runtime", {}, context),
+		).rejects.toBe(failure);
+	});
 	it("classifies every operation exactly once", () => {
 		const classified = [
 			...HOTEL_DATABASE_OPERATIONS,

src/features/housekeeping/domains/hotel/services/mutations-production.ts

@@ -41,6 +41,7 @@ function auditEntry(
 		action: `hotel.${operation}`,
 		target: "Hotel",
 		correlationId: context.correlationId,
+		...(context.reason === undefined ? {} : { reason: context.reason }),
 		domain: "hotel",
 		outcome,
 		before: snapshot?.before ? { ...snapshot.before } : undefined,
@@ -70,16 +71,13 @@ export function createHotelProductionMutationAdapter(
 			}
 
 			await dependencies.writeAudit(auditEntry(operation, context, "intent"));
+			let snapshot: HotelMutationSnapshot;
 			try {
-				const snapshot = await dependencies.executeOperation(
+				snapshot = await dependencies.executeOperation(
 					operation,
 					input,
 					context,
 				);
-				await dependencies.writeAudit(
-					auditEntry(operation, context, "success", snapshot),
-				);
-				return snapshot;
 			} catch (error) {
 				try {
 					await dependencies.writeAudit(
@@ -90,6 +88,21 @@ export function createHotelProductionMutationAdapter(
 				}
 				throw error;
 			}
+			try {
+				await dependencies.writeAudit(
+					auditEntry(operation, context, "success", snapshot),
+				);
+				return snapshot;
+			} catch {
+				return {
+					...snapshot,
+					completion: {
+						status: "partial",
+						external: "completed",
+						audit: "unavailable",
+					},
+				};
+			}
 		},
 	};
 }

src/features/housekeeping/domains/hotel/services/mutations.ts

@@ -1,5 +1,6 @@
 import { PERMS } from "@/lib/permission-slugs";
 import { satisfiesCapability } from "../../../foundation/capability-context";
+import { normalizeHousekeepingReason } from "../../../foundation/commands/reason-policy";
 import {
 	anyCapability,
 	fail,
@@ -48,12 +49,14 @@ export interface HotelMutationInvocation {
 	readonly correlationId: string;
 	readonly expectedActorId: number;
 	readonly legacy?: boolean;
+	readonly reason?: string;
 }
 
 export interface HotelMutationContext {
 	readonly capability: HousekeepingCapabilityContext;
 	readonly correlationId: string;
 	readonly legacy: boolean;
+	readonly reason?: string;
 }
 
 export interface HotelMutationAdapter {
@@ -116,10 +119,12 @@ export function createHotelMutationService(
 				);
 			}
 			try {
+				const reason = normalizeHousekeepingReason(invocation.reason);
 				const snapshot = await adapter.execute(operation, input, {
 					capability,
 					correlationId: invocation.correlationId,
 					legacy: invocation.legacy === true,
+					...(reason === undefined ? {} : { reason }),
 				});
 				return ok(snapshot, invocation.correlationId, snapshot.completion);
 			} catch (error) {